Emerging-Market Short Sales Climb Most Since 2007 (Update1)

By Michael Patterson and Alexander Ragir
April 23 (Bloomberg) -- Short sellers are increasing bets against developing-nation stocks by the most since March 2007, a signal the biggest rally in 16 years may fizzle as profits plunge from Brazil to Taiwan.
Short interest in the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index fund, which tracks equities in 23 developing nations, climbed 51 percent in March, the biggest jump in two years, according to New York Stock Exchange data compiled by Bloomberg. Wagers against Rio de Janeiro-based oil company Petroleo Brasileiro SA’s U.S.-traded shares were the highest since August 2005. Those against display maker AU Optronics Corp. of Hsinchu, Taiwan surged to an eight-month high, the data show.
The growth in short sales, where investors borrow stock and sell it on the expectation prices will fall, marks a shift from the last three rebounds in emerging-market stocks. In those cases traders closed out their bets. The MSCI gauge, up 34 percent from its 2009 low on March 2, may drop 10 percent in coming weeks as falling earnings damp investor optimism, ING Investment Management SA’s Eric Conrads said.
“We aren’t out of the woods,” said Conrads, a Mexico City-based hedge fund manager at ING, which oversees $12 billion in emerging-market assets. Conrads started betting against developing-nation equities this month, convinced the stocks are in a “bear-market rally,” he said.
Bear Market
The MSCI index is down 1.8 percent from a six-month high on April 16, rising 1.2 percent to 636.61 at 11:09 a.m. in London. The iShares fund mimics the performance of the MSCI index and can be bought and sold like a stock.
Traders who increased short positions in the iShares fund during the 40 percent rally in emerging-market stocks from August 2007 to October 2007 proved prescient.
The MSCI gauge peaked at a record 1,338.49 on Oct. 29, 2007, and tumbled 66 percent through Oct. 27 last year, the worst bear market in the index’s 20-year history. The retreat was spurred by a collapse in U.S. consumer spending and a freeze in credit markets that sent the global economy into its first recession since World War II.
MSCI’s emerging-market index climbed as much as 34 percent from October 2008 to January as short sellers ended 52 percent of their bets against the iShares fund on speculation that the worst of the economic contraction was over. As the index kept climbing in March, posting its best month since 1993, short interest surged to 96.1 million shares, or 11 percent of the fund’s total shares outstanding, the NYSE data show.
Petrobras
Bets against American depositary receipts of Petrobras increased 61 percent in March to 34.1 million, or 1.4 percent of the shares available for trading, according to Bloomberg data. Wagers against AU Optronics, the world’s third-largest maker of liquid-crystal displays, climbed 26 percent to 13.1 million, or 1.5 percent of the traded shares, Bloomberg data show. The company gained 17 percent during the month, while Petrobras advanced 9.9 percent.
Short interest in all stocks traded on the NYSE rose 11 percent last month to 4.23 percent of shares outstanding. The NYSE releases short interest data to mid-April at the end of this week.
Equity prices climbed too fast after March 1 given the outlook for earnings, said Martin Herbon, who manages a Latin America hedge fund for Geneva-based Union Capital Group SA.
Trailing Estimates
Emerging-market profits may drop 26 percent this year, according to Citigroup Inc. Taiwan companies may post a 29 percent slide in net income, the steepest decline among developing countries in Asia, and Brazilian earnings may fall 37 percent, the most in Latin America, the New York-based bank said in an April 15 research note.
Twenty-nine of the 41 companies in the MSCI index that posted profits since the end of the first quarter trailed analysts’ estimates, according to Bloomberg data. The gauge trades at 11.4 times earnings, near the most expensive in almost nine months, the data show. At least 256 companies in the index are scheduled to report earnings in the next month.
“Prices have gone up, but the earnings still need some reviews,” said Herbon, who helps oversee $900 million and is using exchange-traded funds to bet on declines in Brazilian shares. This rally “seems too early,” he said.
The MSCI gauge posted an average decline of 1.6 percent during three-month periods following jumps of at least 25 percent in short interest on the iShares fund since 2006, according to Bloomberg data.
False Signals
Increases in short sales sometimes send false sell signals. The MSCI gauge rose 16 percent in three months after a 41 percent jump in short interest in September 2006. When short sales climbed 59 percent in March 2007, the MSCI gauge added 19 percent in the next three months.
Traders are too bearish and the latest equity rally is the beginning of a new bull market, according to Templeton Asset Management Ltd.’s Mark Mobius, Traxis Partners LLC’s Barton Biggs and Fisher Investments Inc.’s Kenneth Fisher, who together oversee more than $40 billion.
“The market is beginning to tentatively price in the likelihood of an economic recovery,” said Christopher Palmer, who helps manage about $4 billion as the London-based head of global emerging markets at Gartmore Investment Management Ltd.
The International Monetary Fund said yesterday that the global recession will be deeper and the recovery slower than previously thought. It’s still too early to turn bullish on emerging-market stocks because there’s a risk the global economy will deteriorate, said Jason Hepner, an Edinburgh-based money manager at Standard Life Investments Ltd., which oversees about $178 billion. Hepner is holding fewer emerging-market shares than are represented in benchmark indexes.
“We’re looking for clear signs of bottoming in global growth before turning positive on emerging-market equities.”